Freelance Money Tools
Retirement

Pay the tax now, or pay it in thirty years?

That's the entire Roth-vs-traditional question. It sounds unanswerable, but for a freelancer with lumpy income it's often clearer than you'd think.

Same-budget comparison, no thumb on the scale
Stays on your device
No account

Tax data last updated: July 2026. Sources & methodology

Your situation

$

The same budget goes into both accounts — that keeps the comparison fair.

%

Your top federal bracket now. Most freelancers sit at 22% or 24%.

%

Lower for most people — spending drops and only withdrawals get taxed.

yrs
%

7% nominal is the boring long-run stock market assumption.

Traditional wins
+$44,274

Deferring tax wins — you skip a high rate now and pay a lower one in retirement.

Traditional, after-tax at withdrawal
$389,614
Roth, tax-free at withdrawal
$345,340

The whole answer hangs on one guess: your tax rate decades from now. Nobody knows it — which is a real argument for splitting money between both account types. Ignores RMDs, state tax, and Roth income limits (though backdoor contributions usually get around those). Not financial advice.

How this is calculated

We give both accounts the same pre-tax budget — the fair comparison most online debates skip. Traditional: the full amount goes in, grows, and gets taxed at your retirement rate on the way out. Roth: tax comes off at today's rate first, the remainder goes in, and withdrawals are free. Both grow at the same assumed return.

Set both tax rates equal and the two results are mathematically identical — the entire decision reduces to whether your rate is higher now or in retirement. That's why lean years are Roth years for freelancers: a 12%-bracket year is the cheapest tax you may ever pay on that money.

Related calculators

Retirement

Solo 401(k) limits

Employee + employer cap in one place.

Retirement

SEP IRA calculator

Roughly 20% of net earnings, pre-tax.

Taxes

Effective tax rate

Your real tax percentage - not just your bracket.

Common questions

You guess, with structure. Most retirees spend less than they earned, and only withdrawals get taxed — so many land in lower brackets. Points against: today's rates are historically low and could rise, and big traditional balances force taxable withdrawals (RMDs). Hence the popular answer: hold some of both.
Income swings. An employee at a steady salary picks one strategy; a freelancer can pick per year — Roth contributions in the $50k year when the bracket is low, traditional deductions in the $150k year when they're worth the most. Volatility becomes a tax tool.
Roth IRA contributions phase out at higher incomes, but the backdoor route (contribute to a traditional IRA, convert) remains standard practice. Better yet: Roth Solo 401(k) contributions have no income limit at all, and the deferral cap is far higher than any IRA's.
That's exactly what the same-pre-tax-budget setup accounts for. The traditional account holds more dollars precisely because they weren't taxed yet — the IRS effectively owns a slice of the balance. This comparison prices that slice in, which is why the tax rates alone decide the winner.